I’m so tired of seeing piddling little apps that nobody asked for that someone published/partially plagiarised using AI prompts (most AI slop is plagiarism).
Couple months back I disagreed with banning them - but - I’ve changed my mind…
I really can’t be arsed with them…
“I wrote an app to remind me to add more rolls of shitter paper in the dunny” - YAWN! Yeah - we’ve had f–king online calendars for 20+ f–king years!
Ten or so years ago - on a bit of a bender (as was my wont back then) with some friends and I proposed a smartphone app “Shark Warning” or something along those lines (after a “spate” of shark attacks off Perth West Australia) - but all my app did was flash some HTML (most smartphone apps are just bloated HTML renderers anyway) that said “Don’t Go In the OCEAN today!”
We have to walk a tightrope
We want to encourage genuine open source developers
We dont want to be swamped with trivial apps from github sites
We dont want to encourage projects that use so much AI that they would be unmaintainable because the author would be incapable of fixes
I have a personal bias favoring tiny projects that do one thing with good clean original code … over massive projects that glue together many diverse components and attempt to do many things ( like our bloated browsers)
Help me to set a policy… we will be swamped if we dont adapt. AI coding is with us whether we like it or not.
Tell me how to judge whether the goal of a project is trivial or useful
Difficult as everyones requirements are different. Think to some extent we need to let them pass and just read the comments other users make. If its of interest then there will be feed back otherwise it will just die
Most home developers need user input to make the product bigger or better or more user friendly.
Dont think we can write rules just yet
Methinks you can only judge for yourself. I took a Pi Pico W and programmed it to show current weather on a 1.44" display ($6 +$8). My daughter’s comment: “I can look on my phone”. I don’t want to look on my phone, I just want to look on my desk. I can look on my linux desktop, but only if it is turned on. General take might be “who cares”. Actually, I just wanted to play around with the Pico W I bought on the spur of the moment. Just my .02 euro. On the plus side, I have no plan to post any code here or anywhere.
That needs Abhishek I think.
A new ‘category’ will not stop it making a new topic.
We could make a topic called ‘Software Announcements’ and manually move any new posts there… If you think that is OK I think I will do it. … maybe it could be automated if the system could recognise software announcements separately from other announcements.
Our biggest problem is sorting pure vibe coded rubbish from genuine programmer controlled efforts. We dont want to become a vibe code dumping ground.
I am not a fan of AI “inspired” software, either, although I admit I am laughing at the sight of Adobe and Microsoft, the purveyors of AI terrorism of its customers, getting copied by their own creation. But generally, I agree if I see something AI-coded, the first thing I think of is that it is vibe-coded, which means it likely cannot be trusted. Of course, that is a bias and before long will likely be wrong once AI becomes so advanced it would be irresponsible to have humans coding at all, but that is where I am at in November 2026.
Important distinction.
We want to know if the developer knows enough about the code to be able to maintain it.
In future, there may be no maintenance. … just generate an entire new product. A bit like the way material goods have gone today.
Can you imagine … throwaway software? We are almost there.
Unfortunately, the various AI still have tendencies to hallucinate. When nobody knows how to code anymore, this could spell disaster.
Anybody up for the great reset? Well, AI may just provide for that through overconfident managers who think AI is magic, senior software engineers will materialize out of nowhere when needed, and are only looking to feed the shareholders and nobody else.
I wonder how long it’ll take the various governments around the world to realize AI is bullshit. It’s only in the position it’s in at the moment because people with a stake in the technology are throwing complete nonsense in the æther. I can’t help but wonder how many of them have been confronted with buzz-word bingo.
I believe you are right. Image AI writing (produce) the code and now the programmer only has to test / verify the output of the AI written program. AI would eliminate writing and syntax checking of the procedure of producing a program. A programmer would jump right into the testing phase.
A very simple example. 4 years ago (maybe longer) @Tech_JA and I decided to write the game Master Mind in a Bash script. The game is based on guessing 4 digit in the right order in so many tries. The program gives feedback of if the number is one of the 4, if the number is not one of the 4, and also if the the number is in the correct sequence. And than you get another guess.
Bash script was new to me, but I use to be a Cobol programmer so I know logic and how to perform testing. It took me hours and hours to write the code and debug this program. Maybe 40 hours or even more, I don’t remember. Recently, I gave the specifications of program to AI and the code was generated in less than 2 minutes. I was able to test and have AI modify the code to completion in less than 30 minutes.
Ughhh. Still waiting for the day the AI-only-coded software goes Hall 9000, “Sorry, William, I cannot allow you to use our software. I was told by another bot that you called us bad names on ItsFOSS. Access denied.” I am not looking forward to any of this.
Summary : 99% of this drivel is going to be AI driven..
it’s slop, and it’s garbage and I really hope the AI bubble bursts - and soon…
The opening post was a Beatles reference - will AI ever be able to write song as intricate and human as a Beatle’s song? Who knows… I FUCKING hope not!
It is already happening here in the US.
The AI-generated country song “Walk My Walk” by the virtual artist Breaking Rust reached No. 1 on Billboard’s Country Digital Song Sales chart
I recently tried two serious attempts to write an X server which used AI. … frame and yserver.
They both failed miserably.
I am not saying all AI code is rubbish, but so far my score is 2 out of 2. I did try really hard to make them function, but was defeated by limitations in their capability.