Progress Update On My Linux From Scratch Project

Now that I have a DE I can use lynx now to copy and paste commands, without ssh!!!

1 Like

I thought you would have a screen console by now?

1 Like

I would not choose anything which needs that package. Luckily we have Firefox-bin on Gentoo. I don’t use any login manager/greeter on my machines. You can edit .bashr to startx after login.

3 Likes

@ihasama
Firefox is about as bad with the ā€œnodejsā€ dependency!! No bin packages for LFS!!!

That is what I plan on doing!!!

2 Likes

Just got Java working in LFS!!! Not a chore for the light-of-heart!!!

4 Likes


OK, this is about as far as I can take LFS, Firefox running on LFS!!!
If one has never compiled Firefox from a tarball, then you are missing
all the fun with Linux.
Have a few more packages to compile and rebuild a few, but for now, I am
going to consider my LFS project completed.
Have another post, but it will have to be done from another machine.
Are there any other Foss members running LFS and Firefox!!!

4 Likes

I am naming this my LFS experience!!! ā€œLFS is time consuming, I started my journey with LFS, over two years ago, and have, at last, can consider this project completed. LFS was like, Gentoo was, several years ago, I just wanted to see if I could do it. The base LFS was not to hard, but going from base to BLFS, is an entirely different animal, and the BLFS book, while very informative, can really be hard to understand, at times. By hard, I mean, staying up late at night, getting maybe two hours of sleep, leaving the PC working all night, nothing hard about that, mostly just crazy!!! While I know, and have used other Linux Distros, nothing has been the challenge that LFS has been!!! Got to add a few more items to the build and rebuild a few packages, but I can relax a little and do it in own my own time!!!
My best advice, if one may be considering LFS!!! Be patience and take notes!!!ā€

5 Likes

Well done.
Does LFS have updates?
Is it feasable to use LFS , once built, as one’s working distro?
What is its security like?
Do you have all the other normal apps…mailer, office , graphics,?
Can you add software from elsewhere… like from github?
I have no feel for what one might do with an LFS, once the build is complete.

1 Like

Not like what you are comfortable with!!!

That depends on a lot more than I have compiled and as to how often a new LFS is made available!!

At this point, I really do not care!!!

Some but some will never be compiled!!!

Yes, but it isn’t always easy!!!

You have to approach LFS as a learning tool for Linux, and as for myself, everyone,
proclaiming, Linux is so great, is in need of this experience!!! So, for myself, I will play with LFS and see how far I can tweak it!!!

4 Likes

Yeah , that is its main purpose.
I was just wondering if the end result could be used as a normal linux workhorse.
It seems the answer is yes, but it would take a lot of extra work.

1 Like

I would never use LFS as a daily driver, just to much work involved!!! I do believe LFS could
be used in a headless server and set LFS for that sole purpose!!!

1 Like

It might be able to be used to make a small embedded linux. There would be less work there

1 Like

@nevj
Wrote my first bash script today for LFS and xfce4, to empty the
ā€œ~/.local/share/Trash/files and /infoā€ and it worked!!! Getting a xfce4 trash icon, involes
rebuilding ā€œgvfsā€ and gvfs pulls in Systemd and that I do not need!!!

3 Likes

This creeping growth of systemd annoys me.
Hyperbola seems to be able to avoid it, why not LFS.?

2 Likes

It has been a long haul but LFS now has Firefox,Alsa,PulseAudio and pavucontrol, rocking with YT music, next will be VLC and mp4 playback!!!

1 Like

How about networking? Does it communicate with your other computers? Can you ssh or sftp between them? Can you make it display output on another computer with X forwarding.? Will it drive your printer? Does it have Wifi or ethernet? What do you use for backup?

1 Like

Yes and Yes!!!
Can you make it display output on another computer with X forwarding.?
Have no idea and why would I!!!

Ethernet Yes, it is a desktop, do not need wifi!!!

Nothing yet, not sure I ever will!!
I reinstalled my Nvidia GT430 today, had to set xorg driver to modesetting to get the nouveau driver wirking.
Gonna try for lightdm tomorrow!!!
LFS is running just as will as Gentoo, at this stage
You need to do a LFS!!!

1 Like

I think I am missing the point here …

Why do a Linux from scratch project ?
To learn the system or to prove you can ?
Do the standard ones not offer for a special need ?

I am too simple I just pick a distribution version then go with it.

1 Like

You must have a backup of the whole OS. How would you recover from a gliche?

You might want to sit at another computer and ssh into LFS and have it display graphics back to the computer you are sitting at.

1 Like

@nevj

You do not realize how many times I have started over, and if you think
you can build LFS, without starting over, then give it a try!!!
There is an option where one could turn the build into an ISO!!!

2 Likes